|
NYU Law School students Jared Wessel,
Delfin Rodriquez, Martin Molina, and
David Bennion made it all the way to the final round of the
2002/03 edition of the WTO Moot Court Competition before ceding victory to the
University of London (UCL) in a hotly contested final held at the WTO
headquarters in Geneva. NYU made it through a tough preliminary round, where
they defeated both the Universite de Geneve and the team they would later meet
in the finals, UCL. For their work in the preliminary rounds, Martin Molina and Delfin Rodriquez both won
honorable mention for 'best oralist'.
In the semi-final round, NYU defeated
Martin-Luther-University of Germany before a three-person panel consisting of
Professor Thomas Cottier, Professor Robert Howse of the University of Michigan
and Ms. Gabrielle Marceau. Pleading for the respondent, Jared
Wessel and David Bennion faced questions from the panel
regarding the interaction of general international law and the WTO.
In the final round, the full team gathered to argue
before a panel consisting of distinguished scholars and practitioners in WTO
Law, many of whom were past Panel and/or Appellate Body members: Prof. Jacques
Bourgeois, Prof. Thomas Cottier, Prof. Claus-Dieter Ehlermann, Prof. Frank
Emmert, Ms. Valerie Hughes, and Prof. Elisabetta Montaguti.
38 teams from Europe and the United States competed in
the preliminary written rounds for twelve places in the final oral rounds. All
participating teams were asked to present memorials - both for the claimant and
for the respondent, which were later judged individually and independently by
two academics. NYU was the only U.S. team admitted to the finals. 
The
competition, organized and cosponsored by the European Law Students Association
(ELSA - www.elsa.org), centers around a
hypothetical trade dispute arising from the imposition of an import ban on fish
products by a large economic bloc on a country that allows the hunting of
whales for scientific purposes in spite of a moratorium on commercial whaling.
The team wishes to thank the Hauser Global Law School
Program, Professor Joseph H.H. Weiler, Professor Iqbal S. Ishar, and Professor
Benedict Kingsbury for all their help and support in making NYU's participation
possible. Hopefully, NYU's participation in this prestigious competition will
be a continuous event. |