Jean Monnet Seminar > Spring Semester 2004


The Jean Monnet Seminar, Spring 2004

Home of the Brave:
American Use of Force since WWII



THE CUBAN QUARANTINE



     
     
1.  MAP OF REGION
 
2.  WAS THE QUARANTINE AUTHORIZED USE OF FORCE? SELF-DEFENSE?  
  2.1  Supportive commentators  
 
  • Editorial Comments (C. G. Fenwick,B. MacChesney, M. S. McDougal" 57 Am. J. Int. L. 588 - 604 (1963).
  • J. M. Raymond, "Legal Implications of the Cuban Crisis" 3 Contemporary Law 126 - 134 (1963).
  • L. Henkin, How Nations Behave (1968) pp. 216 - 242.
  • "Law and Conflict: Changing Patterns and Contemporary Challenges" 57 Proceedings of the American Society of International Law 9 - 17 (1963).
  • A. Chayes, International Crisis and the Role of Law (1974) pp. 41 - 68.
 
  2.2  Critical commentators  
 
  • J. S. Campbell, "The Cuban Crisis and the UN Charter: An Analysis of the United States Position" 16 Stan. L. Rev. 160 - 176 (1963).
  • C. Q. Christol, "Maritime Quarantine: The Naval Interdiction of Offensive Weapons and Associated Materiel to Cuba, 1962" 57 Am. J. Int. L. 526 - 565 (1963).
  • W. L. Standard, "The United States Quarantine of Cuba and the Rule of Law" 49 The Am. Bar Assoc. J. 745 - 748 (1963).
  • W. P. Gerberding, "International Law and the Cuban Missile Crisis" in L. Scheinman and D. Wilkinson (eds.), International Law and Political Crisis: An Analytic Casebook (1968) pp. 175 - 210.
  • "Nuclear Weapons, The World Court and Global Security" 7 Transnat'l L. & Contemp. Probs. 459 - 486 (1997).
 

 
     
   Required Reading  
     
  -

Editorial Comments (C. G. Fenwick, B. MacChesney, M. S. McDougal) 57 Am. J. Int. L. 588 - 604 (1963).

 
  -

J. S. Campbell, "The Cuban Crisis and the UN Charter: An Analysis of the United States Position" 16 Stan. L. Rev. 160 - 176 (1963).

 
       

 
     
   Guiding Questions  
     
 

1) What legal reasoning did the United States rely upon? Which line of reasoning was suspiciously absent?

 
 

2) Was the quarantine an il/legitimate "use of force?" A "threat of use of force?"

 
 

3) To what extent was the UN Charter relevant to the legality the U.S. action? Is there a customary law ("inherent" in international law but) outside the Charter that may be relevant?

 
 

4) Did the Rio Treaty itself violate the UN Charter by authorizing collective armed responses that were not spelled out in Article 51?

 
         
 
Browse
Jean Monnet Seminar
Seminar, Spring 2004
 
Related Links
 
Activities of the Jean Monnet Center




Last updated on September 9th, 2004

Top